TLDR Review: "Maybelline The City Mini Eyeshadow Palette"
Pros
- •Features a welounded palette with a good mix of light, medium, and dark contouring shades, perfect for versatile eye looks.
- •Matte colors are especially suitable for those seeking a natural or subtle finish, including older users.
- •Offers a nice balance of shimmer and flat hues, allowing for both everyday and glam styles.
- •Good staying power throughout the day, with shades that generally hold up without fading.
- •Most shades have decent pigment and blendability, making application smooth and useriendly.
- •Brown and peachy shades are praised for their truo-color payoff and natural appeal.
- •The darker matte purple stands out as a unique addition compared to other drugstore palettes.
- •Users often repurchase this palette, indicating overall satisfaction and brand loyalty.
- •The packaging protects the product well and keeps it intact during transit.
Cons
- •The silver shimmer shade is a letdown, described as muddy and dull with little to no sparkle.
- •Some fallout occurs during application, which can be messy and requires careful handling.
- •Pigmentation is inconsistent; while most shades perform well, a few can feel powdery or weak.
- •Blendability is slightly less smooth compared to similar drugstore palettes, though pigmentation might be better.
- •The palette leans more toward cool, smokey eye looks due to the grey tones, which might not suit everyone’s natural makeup preferences.
- •Using a damp brush might improve application but isn’t a guaranteed fix for the powderiness or fallout issues.
- •Some users found the overall quality to be 'decent' but felt certain shades, especially the silver shimmer, hurt the overall impression.
Bottom Line
The Maybelline New York The City Mini Eyeshadow Palette in Chill Brunch Neutrals is a solid choice if you’re looking for a compact, affordable palette with versatile matte and shimmer shades that suit natural to smokey looks. Just keep in mind that the silver shimmer can disappoint and fallout is noticeable, so applying primer and using gentle techniques is recommended. If you prioritize powdery, highly pigmented neutrals with consistently smooth blends, this palette will generally serve you well, but you might want to try it in person first or consider other drugstore palettes if shimmer impact is a dealbreaker. If you want to explore more options for neutrals with strong pigment and better shimmer quality, feel free to ask — we’re here to help!
Where to Buy
Download ShopSavvy App
Compare prices for anything in real-time, set price alerts, watch for deals by keyword, and much more
Install ShopSavvy Browser Extension
Compare and track prices automatically while you shop online at thousands of websites.
Footer 1
Get ShopSavvy
Subscribe for Updates
Get the latest news, and updates on ShopSavvy. You'll be glad you did!